"I know it was-" huh, he's actually lowering his gun. Alright, the ol' exorcist 'come lick me' number can wait. Another few steps closer, they're almost at a conversational distance now.

"Pot and kettle buddy. Not like I was much better back in our world. I know she told you what happened to me."

Avery rubs above his mouth with his free hand, "I dunno why she still does. I'm in her head and I still can't- I dunno. I don't know. It's... some things are clearer and some are..."

A step or two closer. The best acts start with a grain of truth, and the longer he does sit with the feelings and memories in her head... the more confused he gets.